FU
LinkedIn.
Published · 3 min read
Privacy tools I use and support
TL;DR
- Went back to LinkedIn after years away.
- It demanded a government ID and a selfie.
- All I wanted was to edit a stale profile.
- No deal. This page is the profile now.
What happened
- Hadn't logged in for years.
- Went back to update a profile from a few jobs ago.
- Typed the correct password.
- Got this:
Fair point
- The platform is overrun with bots, fake recruiters, and scam accounts.
- A dormant account logging in from a new device looks stolen.
- Making a robot prove it's a person is a reasonable goal.
For the record
I have a job. It keeps me plenty busy. I'm not looking. This is about how much personal information a company thinks it's owed, not a career move.
Meanwhile, in my inbox
- I use a separate address for every site. This one belongs to LinkedIn alone.
- Mostly job alerts and recruiter pitches.
- They're sure I'm job hunting. I'm not.
The verification email
- The newest one landed right after my login: "Jim, please verify your new device."
- No code. No link. It says to use an authenticator app.
- The footer: "Never miss an update with the LinkedIn app."
- Every road leads to their app.
- Bonus: that avatar in the corner is about 20 years old. That's how often I log in.
Why I said no
- They had better options. I knew the password. They have my email. Either one can carry a one-time code.
- They emailed me anyway. Not with a code. With a pointer back to an app.
- The ask was huge. Install their app. Photograph a government ID. Hand over a face scan.
- The reward was tiny. Edit a few lines of text on a feed of posts about what someone's toddler taught them about B2B sales.
- You can't rotate your face. A leaked password gets reset. A leaked ID and a biometric don't.
The catch
- Some employers require a LinkedIn account for compliance training. Two ways that goes:
- Done right: company single sign-on. No personal profile involved.
- Done cheaply: a personal account. Now that means a government ID and a face scan just to log in.
- If I'm ever asked for an ID and a face scan:
- Then I'll say no.
- The requirement and the refusal are both on the record.
- The "simple" training isn't simple anymore.
So this page is the profile now. Static HTML, source on GitHub. Nobody has to prove they're human to read it.